What Company Has the Most Affordable Homeowners Insurance?

With homeowners insurance premiums on the rise nationwide, finding the most affordable yet reliable provider is a top priority for millions of Americans. While the “cheapest” company can vary by location, several insurers have emerged in 2025 as national leaders in low-cost coverage without sacrificing service.

1. Top 3 Most Affordable Home Insurance Companies in 2025

Based on national averages for $300,000 dwelling coverage:

• State Farm – Average annual premium: $1,320
  Known for generous discounts and bundling options.

• Allstate – Around $1,350/year with great multi-policy savings and digital tools.

• Liberty Mutual – From $1,390/year; flexible policies and home safety discounts.

These averages reflect national data, and actual rates vary by ZIP code, home type, and credit profile.

2. What Affects Home Insurance Prices?

Insurance companies calculate your premium using factors like:

• Location and local risk (wildfires, floods, hurricanes)

• Home value and age

• Roofing materials and building structure

• Credit score and claims history

• Chosen deductible and coverage amounts

For example, Florida and Louisiana typically have much higher rates than Oregon or Vermont, regardless of insurer.

3. How to Get the Best Rate in Your Area

To secure the lowest price:

• Bundle home and auto insurance

• Increase your deductible if affordable

• Install security systems and smoke alarms

• Ask for loyalty, new customer, or claims-free discounts

• Compare quotes from multiple companies

4. Local vs National Insurers

While State Farm and Allstate dominate nationally, some regional or local insurers may offer better pricing based on specific risks in your area. For example:

• Amica Mutual in the Northeast

• Farm Bureau in the South and Midwest

• Auto-Owners Insurance in the Midwest and Plains states

Local agents often have better insight into risk factors and can tailor policies more precisely.

Final Thoughts

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer—but in 2025, State Farm, Allstate, and Liberty Mutual consistently offer the most competitive homeowners insurance rates nationwide. However, your best option depends on your home, region, and personal profile.

Want help comparing home insurance from nearly 100 carriers in one place?
With over 30 years of experience, we’ll make sure you get the best coverage at the lowest price. Send your request today to get your personalized quote.