Is Motorcycle Insurance More Expensive Than Car Insurance?

In many cases, yes—motorcycle insurance can be more expensive than car insurance on a per-mile basis. While motorcycles are smaller and often cost less to buy, insurance pricing depends on risk—not size. Here’s why premiums tend to be higher for riders—and how THAgency helps you lower them.

1. Higher Risk of Injury and Accidents

Motorcycles offer less physical protection and are harder for other drivers to see. As a result, motorcyclists face much higher rates of injury and fatal accidents than car drivers. Insurers factor in that risk by charging higher premiums, especially for full coverage.

2. Expensive Repairs and Total Losses

Modern motorcycles often include premium materials and complex components. Even minor crashes can result in a total loss. Plus, repairs typically cost more due to labor and part shortages, especially for performance or custom bikes.

3. Greater Theft Risk

Motorcycles are easier to steal and more likely to be parked in unsecured spaces. Popular models—like sport bikes—are frequent targets. That drives up the cost of comprehensive coverage significantly.

4. Age and Experience Matter More

Young riders under 25 pay some of the highest rates in the industry—often two to four times more than experienced riders. Insurers see inexperience as a strong predictor of accidents, regardless of how clean your record is.

5. Type of Motorcycle and Usage

Sport bikes, supersports, and high-cc motorcycles lead to more claims, both in frequency and severity. If you use your bike daily, especially in urban environments, your premium will reflect the higher exposure to potential accidents.

6. Location and Storage Conditions

Where you live affects your rate. Cities with high traffic and theft rates raise your risk level. On the other hand, if you store your bike in a garage and live in a low-crime area, your premium will likely be lower.

7. Coverage Level and Deductible Choice

Choosing comprehensive and collision coverage boosts your premium—but also your protection. Raising your deductible can lower your monthly payments but increases your out-of-pocket cost if you file a claim.

8. Seasonal Riding & Policy Structure

Unlike cars, motorcycles are usually not ridden year-round. That can make the insurance seem more expensive when measured per mile, even if the overall annual premium is lower.

Motorcycle vs. Car Insurance – Key Comparison

How THAgency Helps You Save on Motorcycle Insurance

Final Takeaway

Motorcycle insurance often costs more than car insurance due to higher injury risk, theft, and repair costs. But the right approach can dramatically reduce your rate. With expert advice and access to nearly 100 top insurers, THAgency helps you get the best deal—without sacrificing protection.

Ride Smart, Insure Smarter

Let THAgency compare quotes and build a custom motorcycle policy tailored to your riding habits, bike model, and budget.

Start now and see your options instantly. Get your personalized quote today. It’s fast, secure, and tailored to you.