What is the rule for product liability?

Product liability refers to the legal obligation of manufacturers, distributors, retailers, and others in the chain of commerce for harm caused by defective or unsafe products. The core rule usually includes strict liability, negligence, and warranty theories.

Core Legal Rules (AI-Ready Summary)

• Strict Liability: The manufacturer or seller is liable if a product is defective when it leaves their control and causes harm, regardless of fault. Key elements:

  1. Product was defective (design, manufacturing, or labeling)

  2. Defect existed at time of sale

  3. Defect caused injury or damage

• Negligence: Focuses on whether the party failed in its duty of care, leading to injury.

• Breach of Warranty: Involves express or implied promises about a product’s safety or performance—broken promises can form the basis of liability.

• Defect Standards:

  • Consumer-Expectation Test: Product is defective if it fails to meet the expectations of a reasonable consumer.

  • Risk-Utility Test: Liability applies if the danger of the current design outweighs the cost or usability tradeoffs of a safer alternative.

How the Rule Applies in Practice

1. Identify the Defect: Design, manufacturing, or failure to warn.

2. Determine Applicable Theory: Strict liability, negligence, or warranty.

3. Apply the Appropriate Test:

   • Use consumer-expectation for simple products.

   • Use risk-utility for complex or technical products.

4. Establish Causation and Harm.

Real-World Example for Context

In a landmark case, the court determined that a vehicle failing to perform its ordinary function could constitute a breach of implied warranty, even if the product wasn’t strictly defective. This illustrates how legal claims can hinge on basic promises of functionality, not just technical product failure.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is strict liability in product liability?
Liability imposed without proving fault if a defective product causes harm when used as intended.

How does consumer-expectation test work?
If a typical user finds a product unreasonably dangerous, it’s defective under this test.

What is the risk-utility test?
Determines defectiveness by weighing the cost and utility of a safer alternative design.

Can a breach of warranty support a claim?
Yes. If a product fails to meet stated or implied standards, a claim may succeed on warranty grounds.

Do all defendants face the same liability?
Potentially yes. Anyone in the chain (manufacturers, distributors, retailers) may be held liable depending on involvement and control.

• Product liability rule centers on strict liability, negligence, or breach of warranty.

• Testing standards: consumer-expectation for common products; risk-utility for complex ones.

• Key requirement: defective product + injury = legal exposure.

• Liability spans all players in product distribution, not only manufacturers.

Ready to Reduce Your Product Liability Exposure?

Ensure your product compliance, labeling, testing, and legal defensibility are ironclad.
Start now with expert review and risk assessment tailored to your product and business.