Can You Claim Emotional Sufferance Damages?

Strict product liability allows injured consumers to seek compensation without having to prove negligence. But what happens when the harm is emotional rather than physical? Let’s explore whether emotional sufferance damages are recoverable in strict product liability cases in the U.S.

What Is Strict Product Liability?

Strict product liability is a legal doctrine that holds manufacturers, distributors, or retailers liable for defective products, regardless of whether they acted negligently. To win such a claim, the injured party must generally prove:

• The product was defective.

• The defect existed when it left the defendant’s control.

• The defect caused injury.

This concept streamlines justice for consumers injured by dangerous or faulty products.

What Are Emotional Sufferance Damages?

Emotional sufferance (often referred to as emotional distress or mental anguish) refers to non-physical injuries that impact a person’s mental or emotional well-being. These may include:

• Anxiety

• Depression

• Sleep disturbances

• PTSD

• Loss of enjoyment of life

While commonly pursued in personal injury and negligence cases, their role in strict product liability is more complex.

Are Emotional Damages Recoverable in Strict Product Liability?

Yes, but with limitations. In the U.S., courts vary in how they treat emotional damages in strict liability cases. Here’s a breakdown:

✅ When Emotional Damages Are Allowed:

1. Emotional Distress Accompanied by Physical Injury
   If a defective product causes both physical harm and emotional trauma, damages for both may be awarded.

2. Emotional Injury Leading to Physical Symptoms
   Courts may recognize emotional distress if it results in physical manifestations like ulcers, chronic headaches, or panic attacks.

3. Close Proximity to the Danger
   In some cases, plaintiffs who narrowly escaped physical harm may claim emotional damages even without actual injury (e.g., a product explodes near them).

Challenges in Recovering Emotional Sufferance Damages

While possible, these claims often face legal hurdles:

• Proof of Serious Emotional Distress
  Plaintiffs must often demonstrate the severity and legitimacy of the emotional injury through medical or psychiatric evidence.

• State-by-State Variance
  Laws differ by state. Some jurisdictions are more favorable to emotional damage claims, while others strictly require physical harm.

• Economic vs. Non-Economic Damages
  Emotional damages are non-economic and harder to quantify, making them more challenging to win and justify to a jury or insurer.

Key Examples

• Defective car brakes causing a crash that leads to PTSD may result in recoverable emotional damages.

• Toxic chemical exposure from a faulty product that triggers severe anxiety or panic attacks could qualify in some courts.

• Exploding phone battery that causes burns and trauma can support both physical and emotional claims.

Should You Pursue a Claim?

If you’ve suffered emotionally due to a dangerous product, speak with an attorney familiar with product liability and personal injury law in your state. Your claim may be viable, especially if emotional harm is significant and well-documented.

Final Thoughts

Emotional sufferance damages in strict product liability cases are legally complex but not impossible. While they aren’t always awarded, they can be pursued when emotional harm is severe, medically verified, and linked to a defective product. Understanding your state’s laws and building a strong, evidence-based case is essential for success.

Need help evaluating your insurance exposure as a business or individual? We search nearly 100 carriers to get you the best price for the best coverage. Fill out the form below to get your personalized quote. Start now and see your options instantly. Get your personalized quote today. It’s fast, secure, and tailored to you.