Why Adding Teen Drivers Skyrockets Car Insurance Costs

Including a teen driver on your policy dramatically increases insurance costs due to their significantly higher risk profile. Below is a detailed breakdown of what drives those skyrocketing premiums and key strategies to manage them.

1. High-Risk Teen Drivers

Teen drivers (ages 16–19) are statistically the most accident-prone age group — up to three times more likely to be involved in serious crashes than adults. Their inexperience, distracted driving, and risk-taking behavior make insurers view them as high risks.

2. Dramatic Premium Increases

Adding a teenager can increase your premium by 50% to 200%, depending on their age, gender, and location. On average, rates jump around 79–82% simply by adding a teenage driver.

3. Differences by State

Some states — like Rhode Island, Wyoming, and Louisiana — often see increases exceeding 200%, while others, like Hawaii, show minimal rate hikes due to local laws prohibiting age- and gender-based pricing.

4. Impact of Gender and Age

Male teens generally cost more to insure — often resulting in 90–112% increases vs. around 70–87% for female teens. Premiums decrease gradually as teens gain driving experience, especially by age 19.

5. Average Total Cost

On average, adding a teen raises premiums by about $3,250–3,600 annually, or roughly $250–300 per month. Some standalone policies for teens can cost over $5,000 per year.

6. Ways to Lower the Cost

There are proven strategies to ease the expense:

• Driver education and good-student discounts can cut premiums by 5–20%.

• Usage-based insurance — using telematics to monitor safe driving — can save up to 40%.

• Choosing safer, more modest cars, increasing deductibles, and bundling policies also help.

• Check if your state offers special programs or credits for teen drivers.

7. Long-Term Outlook

Although expensive initially, rates drop as teens gain experience. After 3–5 years of safe driving, the premium differences diminish — rewarding both safety and patience.

Final Takeaway

Teen drivers can double or triple your insurance rates due to their risk profile. However, driver training, discounts, telematics, and careful vehicle choices can significantly reduce costs. Over time, safe habits will help teens earn lower rates.

Ready to Protect Your Teen and Your Budget?

Request a personalized quote today. Find coverage that suits your family and rewards safe driving.